PAST GRAND HIGH PRIESTS
| 1804 | * Jonathan Wells. | Rutland | 1942 | * Walter F. Chapman | Rutland |
| 1805-08 | * Caphan Smith, Jr | Rutland | 1943 | * Dana S. Brownell | Springfield |
| 1809 | * Issac Tichenor | Bennington | 1944 | * Alton G. Wheeler | Proctor |
| 1810-12 | * Ozias Fuller | Rutland | 1945 | * Alexander Rae | Barre |
| 1813-15 | * John Chipman | Middlebury | 1946 | * Charles Von Bruns | Burlington |
| 1816-17 | * Charles Williams | Rutland | 1947 | * Henry Springstead | Bradford |
| 1818-21 | * John H. Cotton | Windsor | 1948 | * Edward S. Pike | Rutland |
| 1822-24 | * Lemeul Whitney | Brattleboro | 1949 | * Clarence O. Baker | Brandon |
| 1825-26 | * John H. Cotton | .Windsor | 1950 | * Clayton S. Rice | White River Jct. |
| 1827-29 | * Joel Clapp | Shelburne | 1951 | * Arthur D. Bishop | Montpelier |
| 1830 | * Silas Bowen | Clarendon | 1952 | * Lawrence Williams | Arizona |
| 1831-51 | * Nathan Haswell | Burlington | 1953 | * Harry L. Cummings | Bradford |
| 1852-57 | * Philip C. Tucker | Vergennes | 1954 | * Harold P.Blake | Rutland |
| 1858 | * John S. Webster | Burlington | 1955 | * Frank M. Brownell | Arlington |
| 1859 | * Thomas A Campbell | St. Albans | 1956 | * J.Wesley Murdock,Sr | Middlebury |
| 1860-62 | * Brazillai Davenport | Brandon | 1957 | * Lionel Burdick | Ludlow |
| 1863-64 | * Gamaliel Washburn | Montpelier | 1958 | * Arthur E. Dietrich | Wisconsin |
| 1865 | * Leverett Englesby | Burlington | 1959 | * Ernest Davenport | Barton |
| 1866 | * Edward S. Dana | New Haven | 1960 | * Ernest F. Miles | Bennington |
| 1867-69 | * Charles A. Miles | Brattleboro | 1961 | * Chas. P. Mason | Rutland |
| 1870-72 | * Edward S. Jewell | Burlington | 1962 | * Hermand Hertzberg | Brattleboro |
| 1873-74 | * John A. Clark | Montpelier | 1963 | * Joseph T. Maclay | S. Strafford |
| 1875-78 | * Edward S. Dana | New Haven | 1964 | * Bernard Bryant | Alburg |
| 1879-90 | * Alfred A. Hall | St. Albans | 1965 | * Huntress B. Clark | Windsor |
| 1881-82 | * Homer M. Phelps | Burlington | 1966 | * Reginal Barnard | Brandon |
| 1883-86 | * Kittridge Haskins | Brattleboro | 1967 | * Ralph E. Berry | St. Albans |
| 1887-88 | * Marsh O. Perkins | Windsor | 1968 | * Thomas D. Kendall | Newport |
| 1889-90 | * Edwin O. Hibbard | Randolph | 1969 | Morris G. Tucker | Rutland |
| 1891-92 | * George W. Wing | Montpelier | 1970 | * Harold A. Davis | Montpelier |
| 1893-94 | * Myron J. Horton | Poultney | 1971 | * Waldon C. Biggs | Randolph |
| 1895 | * Robert J. Wright | Newport | 1972 | * Roland J. Bishop | Springfield |
| 1896 | * Daniel Nicholson | Burlington | 1973 | * George R. Cummings | Windsor |
| 1897 | * Eugene S. Weston | New Haven | 1974 | * George H. Stone | Orleans |
| 1898 | * Orland W. Sherwan | Woodstock | 1975 | * Raymond F. Sutton | Rutland |
| 1899 | * Charles Calderwood | St. Johnsbury | 1976 | * Clyde H. Putnam | Arlington |
| 1900 | * Charles Williams | Bellows Falls | 1977 | * Welland S. Horn | Brandon |
| 1901 | * Daniel Danforth | St. Albans | 1978 | * Theodore Boisvert | St. Albans |
| 1902 | * William L. Boyce | Woodstock | 1979 | James E. Selleck | Middlebury |
| 1903 | * William S. Terrill | Rutland | 1980 | * Cedric L. Smith | Barre |
| 1904 | * Daniel Payson | Windsor | 1981 | + Stephen J. Marshall | White River Jct. |
| 1905 | * Delos M. Bascom | St. Johnsbury | 1982 | * Percy W. Birchard. | Montpelier |
| 1906 | * David A Elliott | Island Pond | 1983 | * Rodney A. Akers | White River Jct. |
| 1907 | * Collins Blakely | Montpelier | 1984 | * Warren W. Pond | Brattleboro |
| 1908 | * Olin Daley | White River Jct. | 1985 | * Gleason W. Ayers | Waterbury |
| 1909 | * Edwin H. Martin | Middlebury | 1986 | * David E. Cumming | Barre |
| 1910 | * Henry S. Root | Newport | 1987 | * Donald C. Brown | Williamstown |
| 1911 | * Samuel T. Braley | Rutland | 1988 | * Brent N. Martin | Brookfield |
| 1912 | * Henry D. Bryant | Morrisville | 1989 | Willis J. Morse | Waterbury |
| 1913 | * Silas Danforth | St. Albans | 1990 | Palmer E. Martin | Williamstown |
| 1914 | * Don A. Stone | Burlington | 1991 | * Clyde T. Reynolds | Bethel |
| 1915 | * Harry J. Stannard | Barton | 1992 | * Arthur W. Clough | Chester |
| 1916 | * James A. Roberts | Burlington | 1993 | Arnold G. Preston | Chelsea |
| 1917 | * George N. Tilden | Barre | 1994 | ++ Aurele Gagne | Highgate Center |
| 1918 | * Wm. Brewster | Middlebury | 1995 | Russell A. Goslant | Middlesex |
| 1919 | * George Whitney | Bellows Falls | 1996 | William W. Smith | Newport |
| 1920 | * Charles A. Lang | Montpelier | 1997 | * Donald W. Gerrish | Burlington |
| 1921 | * Chrstie Crowell | Brattleboro | 1998 | James B. Winner, III | Middlebury |
| 1922 | * George F. Root | Newport | 1999 | * Hebert H. Harford | Windsor |
| 1923 | * Allen D. Ball | Ludlow | 2000 | Belford A. Belles | Thetford |
| 1924 | * Archie Harrington | Middlebury | 2001 | Daniel Ebbighausen | Windsor |
| 1925 | * Roger S. Pike | Rutland | 2002 | ++ Stephen E. Holcomb | Hardwick |
| 1926 | * Edwin B. Clift | Fair Haven | 2003 | Donald C. Murray | Graniteville |
| 1927 | * Raymond Pearl | St. Johnsbury | 2004-05 | ^ Guy W. Oldenburgh | Westford |
| 1928 | * Arthur D. Young | Barre | 2006 | * Eugene C. Corliss | Waterbury Ctr |
| 1929 | * H. Perley Clark | Woodstock | 2007 | E. Lawrence Douglass, Jr | Rutland |
| 1930 | * Cady L. Earle | St. Albans | 2008 | David H. Bartlett | Williamstown |
| 1931 | * Aaron H. Grout | Burlington | 2009 | Russell J. Slora | Barre |
| 1932 | * Richard T. Bunker | Poultney | 2010 | Bruce R. Howard | Rutland |
| 1933 | * Edw. W. Curtis | Rutland | 2011 | Kirk C. White | Bethel |
| 1934 | * Max S. Ayers | Waterbury | 2012 | Pierre-Denis Leger | Quebec |
| 1935 | * Henry H. Ballou | Chester | 2013 | Alexis J. Parent, Jr. | Richmond |
| 1936 | * Truman J. Allen | Brandon | 2014 | Douglas K. Boardman | Chelsea |
| 1937 | * Arthur Anderson | Barre | 2015 | Jonathan P. Park | Norwich |
| 1938 | * Alfred Bishop | Newport | 2016 | William Karstens, IV | Williston |
| 1939 | * J. Alfred Stacey | Windsor | 2017 | Eric C. Steele | Burlington |
| 1940 | * Floyd T. Sumner | Ludlow | 2018 | David W. Schuler | Jericho |
| 1941 | ** Chas. A. Haight | Vergennes | | | |
** Deceased in Office + Dropped from Blue Lodge
* Deceased ^ Howard Hatt elected but not installed ++ Demitted
|
