| * Sir Knight James Clement Ford | 6/14/1965 | Sir Knight Stuart E. Lee | 6/15/1994 |
| * Sir Knight Frederick Alexander Inglis | 6/6/1966 | * Sir Knight Robert Farrington | 6/26/1995 |
| * Sir Knight C. Houghton Hoisington | 6/5/1967 | * Sir Knight Willard B. Farnham | 5/27/1996 |
| * Sir Knight Wayne Davis | 6/1/1968 | Sir Knight Arnold G. Preston | 6/1/1997 |
| * Sir Knight Harold William Yasinski | 5/24/1970 | * Sir Knight Russell A. Goslant | 6/8/1998 |
| * Sir Knight George Hamilton Thomas | 5/22/1971 | * Sir Knight Robert S. Boyce | 6/7/1999 |
| * Sir Knight Roger Fred Spaulding | 5/29/1972 | * Sir Knight Brent N. Martin | 6/12/2000 |
| * Sir Knight Thomas Kenneth Pauley | 6/3/1973 | * Sir Knight Stuart J. Gasson | 6/11/2001 |
| * Sir Knight Thomas Dixon Kendall | 6/2/1974 | * Sir Knight Clyde T. Reynolds | 6/10/2002 |
| * Sir Knight Ralph C. Watson | 6/2/1975 | * Sir Knight Jon E. Babcock | 6/9/2003 |
| * Sir Knight Joseph J. Bianchi | 5/25/1976 | * Sir Knight Elmer M. Barlow | 6/7/2004 |
| * Sir Knight Thomas B. Alexander | 6/11/1977 | * Sir Knight Eugene C. Corliss | 6/13/2005 |
| * Sir Knight Kenneth C. Elliott | 6/5/1978 | Sir Knight Roland F. Godin | 6/12/2006 |
| * Sir Knight John S. Birkett | 6/4/1979 | Sir Knight William H. Grant, Jr. | 6/4/2007 |
| * Sir Knight Richard Simpson | 6/1/1980 | ^ Sir Knight John T. Colby | 6/9/2008 |
| * Sir Knight Jack E. Wendell | 6/1/1981 | Sir Knight Robert H. Landon | 6/8/2009 |
| * Sir Knight Robert J. O’Hara | 5/24/1982 | Sir Knight Riford "Mike" Tuttle | 6/7/2010 |
| * Sir Knight Roy Wayne Ingraham | 6/5/1983 | * Sir Knight Jonathan P. Park | 6/13/2011 |
| * Sir Knight Frank H. Caffin | 6/6/1984 | ^ Sir Knight Nicholas D. Ruby | 6/11/2012 |
| Sir Knight Phillip D. Goss | 5/27/1985 | Sir Knight Winston Harper | 6/10/2013 |
| * Sir Knight Harry E. Frost | 6/2/1986 | Sir Knight William Smith | 6/9/2014 |
| * Sir Knight Kenneth A. Laplant | 6/1/1987 | Sir Knight Everett Dickinson | 6/8/2015 |
| * Sir Knight Fletcher H. Hall | 6/5/1988 | Sir Knight Edward Nowatka | 6/13/2016 |
| * Sir Knight James R. Slora | 6/5/1989 | Sir Knight Joshua Retchless | 6/12/2017 |
| * Sir Knight Karsten Larsen | 6/12/1990 | Sir Knight Robert Lencke | 6/10/2019 |
| ^ Sir Knight Aurele Gagne | 6/3/1991 | Sir Knight Leo LaFlamme | 6/12/2021 |
| * Sir Knight Omlah R. Smith, Jr | 6/5/1992 | | |
| * Sir Knight Donald W. Gerrish | 5/31/1993 | | |
| * Deceased | | | |
| ^ Demitted | | | |
